Opens in a new tab

Cesar Peres Dulac Müller Blog

ARTICLES & NEWS

Condominium Dues Are Excluded from Judicial Reorganization: Understanding the Superior Court of Justice’s Ruling

Brazil’s Superior Court of Justice (STJ) held that condominium dues are excluded from judicial reorganization proceedings and classified as claims outside those proceedings. In practice, this means that financially distressed companies cannot include overdue condominium dues in their reorganization plans, and condominium associations retain the right to recover the full amounts owed through the ordinary courts.

The Court’s Second Section issued the ruling under the procedure for repetitive appeals (Theme 1.391), making its holding binding on all courts in Brazil.

Why are condominium dues treated differently?The ruling turns on the legal nature of the obligation to pay condominium dues, which is classified as propter rem, meaning that the debt attaches to the property itself and is not merely a personal obligation of the individual or company that owns it.

Protecting the interests of all unit owners. Allowing a company to suspend payment of condominium dues would burden the other unit owners, leading to unwarranted special assessments and unjust enrichment of the debtor.

Preserving cash flow. Unlike commercial suppliers or financial institutions, a condominium association operates without a profit margin and does not participate in the credit market. Its revenue serves solely to cover immediate maintenance expenses.

Practical Implications

The Court’s holding directly affects both condominium management and companies undergoing restructuring:

Collection in the ordinary civil courts. The condominium association may pursue its claim without filing it in the judicial reorganization proceedings for payment alongside other creditors. Any collection action or proceeding to enforce the debt instrument continues directly before the ordinary civil court.

No reductions or grace periods. The condominium association’s claim is exempt from the reductions, extended installment schedules, and waivers commonly approved under reorganization plans. The amount owed must be paid in full, including interest, inflation adjustments, and any late-payment penalty.

Collection of older and more recent debts. The rule applies even to debts incurred before the company filed for judicial reorganization, overriding the general rule that freezes preexisting debts.

Asset seizure. Although enforcement proceeds in the civil court, the judicial reorganization court retains jurisdiction to determine whether any attachment would affect capital assets shown to be essential to the company’s operations.

The STJ’s adoption of a binding holding under Theme 1.391 gives condominium associations greater legal certainty and financial predictability by providing faster means of recovering revenue essential to their operations. Condominium management companies and association managers should promptly review any claims that have been stayed or improperly admitted in judicial reorganization proceedings so that collection can proceed through the appropriate procedural channels. Companies considering filing for judicial reorganization should exercise caution in formulating their strategy and take into account the rule now formalized by the STJ.

Civil Law | CPDMA Team

Contact our team

Contact us to discuss your company's legal needs.